News

Ask Damon: What Keeps the Wing Aloft?

I am often asked how our airborne wind turbines stay in the air. Our understanding of physics hinges on the observation that energy is never created or destroyed. If we generate power to put it on the grid, we have to take it from somewhere, which in the case of an AWT or a wind turbine, is the kinetic energy carried by the wind. When you are driving down the freeway and hit the brake pedal, the brakes are extracting kinetic energy from the car that heat the brake rotors, or in a hybrid car, charge the batteries. For a given volume of air interacting with the wing, it slows down the volume of air and extracts energy.

The wing harvests kinetic energy by creating lift. One rough approximation, close enough to reality for our purposes, is that the wing pushes on a tube of air equal in diameter to the span of the wing. Because the lift is not exactly opposite the wind, the air is actually pushed slightly downward or back from the wing. This force leaves some momentum in the air, moving opposite the direction of motion of the wing.

This is not the whole story. The wing is gaining energy, which would make it accelerate. However, the onboard turbines are dragging the volume of air they interact with along with them, generating power and keeping the wing at a constant velocity. The volume of air that interacts with just the wing is left moving slightly opposite the motion of the wing, and the volume of air which interacts with both the wing and the turbines is left moving slightly with the wing. In this idealized example, if the turbines somehow interacted with the exact same volume of air as the wing, the wake could leave no energy behind. This points to one of the nice synergies of our system: Because the rotors are interacting with much of the same air as the wing, the overall efficiency of the system is higher than it would be if the two components were separated.

We can tie this idea of energy and slowing a volume of air to an image we are more familiar with. A drop of water hitting a pool has momentum, and behaves in much the same way as the air the AWT interacts with: the ambient fluid must push out of the way of the disturbed fluid. The two begin to roll up and mix. This transfer of momentum is called vortex shedding or wake rollup. It is what we see in classic images of things as large as a 747 or the M600, or as small as a drop of dye in a cup of water.

 

 

  • AWT

    A wind based energy generation device with at least one airborne element. The Makani AWT consists of a rigid wing with mounted turbines that flies in circles across the wind at 300 meters (1,000 feet) above ground level.x

    Airborne Wind Turbine

    A wind based energy generation device with at least one airborne element. The Makani AWT consists of a rigid wing with mounted turbines that flies in circles across the wind at 300 meters (1,000 feet) above ground level.x

    Airborne Wind Turbines

    A wind based energy generation device with at least one airborne element. The Makani AWT consists of a rigid wing with mounted turbines that flies in circles across the wind at 300 meters (1,000 feet) above ground level.x

    Autonomous Controller

    An on-board computer that controls the flight path of the wing by changing the position of the control flaps.x

    Avionics

    The electronic backbone of the AWT. Avionics include the sensors, actuators, controllers and communication systems that keep the wing flying on its desired path.x

    Capacity factor

    The average power output divided by the name plate power output of a power plant. Capacity factor demonstrates the frequency with which a power plant is running at its name plate capacity.x

    COE

    Cost of Energy or the total cost to generate energy that is fed into the grid.

    Firming Power

    The outside power generation needed to stabilize the flow of electricity to the grid when an inconsistent resource, like wind or solar, creates less electricity than needed.x

    Ground Station

    The base station for the AWT, includes a winch for retrieval of the wing and storage of the tether.x

    Car vs. AWT

    A typical compact car weighs about 1.2 tons and produces about 30 kW during the 10 seconds it takes to slow from 25 m/s (50 mph) to a stop. Each cubic meter (~1.2 cubic yards) of air weighs only .0012 tons and a good wind day might be traveling at 25 mph (11 m/s), so Wing 7 would have to to interact with 350 cubic meters of air (about 23 dump trucks worth) every second to extract an equal amount of power. In reality it is not as efficient to design an AWT to completely halt the air it interacts with, so we design our AWTs to exert a smaller force on an even larger body of air.x

    Material efficiency

    Material efficiency refers to how much power is output in relation to the raw material needed for construction of the generator.x

    Rated power

    The amount of power a plant delivers when operating at full capacity.x

    Rated capacity

    The amount of power a plant delivers when operating at full capacity.x

    Rotors

    The rotors capture the accelerated wind as it rushes across the wing and convert it into electrical power with small, direct drive generators. The hybrid rotors can act as propellers as well as turbines, allowing the wing to stay aloft if the wind dies.x

    Turbines

    The rotors capture the accelerated wind as it rushes across the wing and convert it into electrical power with small, direct drive generators. The hybrid rotors can act as propellers as well as turbines, allowing the wing to stay aloft if the wind dies.x

    Tether

    The tether is made of high strength fibers surrounding a conductive core. The tether carries the traction force of the wing and transmits the electrical power to the ground station.x

    Tethered

    The tether is made of high strength fibers surrounding a conductive core. The tether carries the traction force of the wing and transmits the electrical power to the ground station.x

    Usable land

    Factors that influence whether land is usable include site geography, ecology, and wind patterns, for example. x